The U.S. Sentencing Commission reduced the recommended prison sentences for people convicted of fraud, embezzlement, and other financial crimes in an amendment that took effect November 1. That means the starting point for sentencing for economic crimes is lower than it has been in more than a decade.
Amendment 838 raises the monetary thresholds in the fraud tables, which are used to calculate sentences in economic cases. The change recognizes that inflation has eroded the value of the dollar since the thresholds were last adjusted in 2015.
For some defendants, the sudden change in guidelines could mean a reduction of a year or more in the recommended Guidelines prison sentence.
How the Fraud Sentencing Guidelines Work
Federal fraud sentences begin with a base offense level of six or seven. Section 2B1.1 of the United States Sentencing Guidelines directs judges to add levels based on the amount of financial loss. Each level translates to additional time in prison.
The larger the loss, the greater the increase. Other enhancements may apply for abusing a position of trust, sophisticated means, or targeting vulnerable victims, such as the elderly. The resulting “total offense level,” together with the defendant’s criminal history, yields an advisory Guidelines sentencing range. Although judges do not have to impose a sentence within the Guidelines range, the calculation remains the starting point for federal sentencing under Supreme Court precedents.
What Changed on November 1?
The new §2B1.1 loss table raises the dollar thresholds while retaining the existing 16-tier structure.
Some examples:
| Increase | Previous threshold | New threshold |
|---|---|---|
| 8 levels | $95,000 | $150,000 |
| 12 levels | $250,000 | $350,000 |
| 16 levels | $1.5 million | $2 million |
| 18 levels | $3.5 million | $5 million |
| 20 levels | $9.5 million | $15 million |
Each threshold applies when the loss exceeds the stated amount.
Last month, for example, a person responsible for a $100,000 fraud would have received an eight-level enhancement. The new table adds only six levels.
The Sentencing Commission estimates that approximately 23% of cases sentenced under § 2B1.1 would be affected, based on fiscal year 2024 data. Commission modeling projects an average sentence reduction from 35 to 28 months among affected defendants.
The amendment does not rewrite the rules for calculating financial loss or eliminate the other sentencing enhancements.
A Recent Federal Sentencing Illustrates the Difference
In a recent federal fraud case handled by ZMO Law, a defendant faced sentencing for conduct involving just under $10 million.
If the former guidelines had been applied, the defendant received a 20-level loss enhancement. After accounting for the other adjustments, the total offense level was 28, producing an advisory prison range of 78 to 97 months.
Under Amendment 838, the same loss generates only an 18-level enhancement. Assuming the other adjustments remain unchanged, the total offense level falls to 26, with a recommended range of 63 to 78 months. Given the imminent change, the judge was willing to take the new Guidelines into account in his reasoning, and sentenced our client to much less.
In other words, the Guidelines change caused a 15-month reduction to the bottom of the reccommended sentencing range.
What Have the Courts Said?
Not too many courts have yet addressed Amendment 838 in written decisions.
In United States v. Verne, No. 24-270 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 4, 2026), a federal judge rejected a defendant’s claim that his attorneys were ineffective for failing to argue for application of then-pending amendments. The court noted that the adopted inflation adjustment would not have helped that defendant becauae a $24.6 million loss triggered the same 20-level enhancement under both tables. So the new amendment can’t benefit every defendant, and courts generally apply the guidelines in effect at sentencing rather than proposed future changes.
An earlier Second Circuit decision, United States v. Algahaim, 842 F.3d 796 (2d Cir. 2016), remains irelevant, because their, the appeals court recognized that large loss enhancements and low base offense levels, can produce disproportionate sentencing ranges. Judges may consider that imbalance when deciding whether a below-guidelines sentence is appropriate. Put another way, loss amount is a poor proxy for culpability and can be disregarded in appropriate cases.
Can People Already Sentenced Benefit?
There is a distinction between pending and completed cases. Under Guidelines §1B1.11, courts generally use the Guidelines Manual in effect on the sentencing date, subject to constitutional restrictions and the requirement to apply the manual as a whole.
Thus, defendants sentenced after November 1 will generally receive the benefit of the new loss table even if their crimes occurred years earlier.
But Amendment 838 has not been made retroactive under §1B1.10. Someone serving a final sentence will not obtain a reduction under 18 U.S.C. §3582(c)(2) based solely on the amendment.
Cases involving appeals, resentencing, or other grounds for relief require individual review and th enew Guideline does not hurt.
The Problem With Sentencing by Spreadsheet
The inflation adjustment is welcome, but it does not resolve the underlying problem: the unfairness of mechanical table-based sentencing. A million-dollar fraud aimed at hundreds of poor victims is not the same as a million-dollar theft from a large financial institution. But the loss table begins with the same number.
Federal law requires judges to consider far more: the defendant’s culpability, the harm to victims, personal history, rehabilitation, deterrence, and the need to impose a sentence no greater than necessary.
The new guidelines correct an outdated mathematical calculation. They do not replace the need for individualized justice.
For defendants facing federal fraud charges or sentencing, examining the amended loss table should now be an essential part of the defense. If you are facing federal fraud charges, please contact us or call our office at (212) 685-0999.